Drug Education Blog

Ethics and Effective School Policy

Posted January 22, 2013 by Cindy Andrew

A growing international body of research demonstrates that restorative action-based practices in schools contribute to safer and more productive learning environments for both staff and students (Skiba & Sprague for ASCD, 2008).

A recent study by the Consortium on Chicago School Research also finds that it is the quality of the relationships between students and staff and between staff and parents that create safe schools (Justice Policy Institute, 2011).

In addition, evidence suggests that a better way to handle substance use in schools is to focus on restoring the social bonds and relationships that are crucial for building personal resiliency. In other words, schools may get better results from promoting health and healthy relationships than from adding threats of punishment to the learning environment.

These issues are discussed in a new School Policy Brief on The Ethics of Risk and Resilience. The table below indicates elements of effective school policies to address the harms related to substance use.

Decrease Probability of Risk Events

Decrease Effect of Risk Events

Promote activities that allow exploration and celebration of various ways of expression and achievement

Offer ways for students to experience and manage risk in relatively controlled environments

Clearly articulate school and community expectations relative to substance use and other behaviours

Promote restorative practice and other measures to address non-compliance that increase rather than decrease connectedness

Provide safe, inclusive and engaging environments for all students

Teach health literacy skills that promote individual and social responsibility to all students

 

Other helpful links for supporting a more effective approach:

Health Promoting Policies to build school connectedness and foster social and emotional competence

Health-Promoting School Environments to ensure students feel safe from physical and emotional harm, secure in their relationships with teachers and peers, and valued as important members of their school

 

Previous Page | Next Page

About this Blog

This blog is managed by the Knowledge Exchange team at CARBC. Articles are selected to support the application of comprehensive school health approach in addressing substance use in K-12 schools in British Columbia.

If you would like to submit an article for publication in this blog, please send it to helpingschools@carbc.ca.